Abstract
With Indian Civil Service we refer to the bureaucracy that helps run the administrative machinery of the country. India is a parliamentary democracy which basically means that it is a government of the people, from the people and government for the people. The elected representatives have been entrusted with governing the nation. But governing a huge and diverse country like India is a job that can’t be achieved by handful of elected people. It is here that the role of bureaucracy becomes critical. The elected representatives decide the policies and decisions and the bureaucracy helps them in the process and eventually carries out the desired decisions. It is noteworthy to know that the civil servants serve at the pleasure of the President of India and Article 311 of the constitution provides adequate protections and freedom to the civil servants to carry out their duties in the best of their abilities. In this term paper , we try to take a look at the evolution of the Indian Civil Service.
A Background
India is a vast country with a huge diversity in all spheres of life, be it culture, language, traditions, etc. Governing such a huge territory and population, India is the seventh largest country in the world by land and second largest by population, is a tough ask for any nation, but keeping in mind India’s diversity and strategic location, it becomes all the more momentous. It is home to almost all the religions including Hinduism, Sikhism, Islam, Christianity, Buddhism, Jainism, Zoroastrianism, etc. and the ancient Indus Valley civilization and trade routes in the past, administering India poses a great challenge. In ancient times, India was ruled by the great Mauryan dynasty in the most part of the present India to the Cholas, Cheras and Pandyas in the south. India at that time saw great administrators and policy makers in the form of Ashoka and Chanakya. In medieval times, India consisted of regional kingdoms led by different rulers. While Harsha of Kannauj ruled the Indo- Gangetic plains, there were Chalukyas in the Deccan and Palas in the east, Pallavas ruled south of Deccan and Cholas and Pandyas still further south. Till the early 16th century, the northern parts were ruled mainly by Muslim rulers whose authority was challenged by the central Asian fighters, leading to the formation of the Mughal Empire which peaked under commendable rule of Akbar the Great. In the northern and western parts, there were the new regional rulers growing up in strength like the Marathas, the Rajputs, and the Sikhs. As the Mughal Empire disintegrated, feudal lords started emerging who had command over their small land holdings. Subsequently, the British came to India to set up the East India Company in 1600. Gradually, the British then grew in strength and from traders they came to rule India, thus setting up the British Raj in the long run. After the victory in Battle of Plassey in 1757, the company was faced with the entirely new task which was to govern the large population and vast areas of Bengal initially, but practically the whole of India later on. The solution that the East India Company came up was the establishment of perhaps the first of its type bureaucracy it invented in response to this challenge was perhaps the first modern bureaucracy in the world which was not accountable to any rulers of Kings but to the company’s Board of Directors.
Bureaucracy in the Pre-independence Period
To answer the challenges the Company faced, it started off by establishing a Covenanted Civil Service (CCS) whose affiliates had to agree to ‘good behavior covenants’ with the Company’s Court of Directors [1], [2]. The company officers were covenanted to provide a lifetime of service. The first step in a number of reforms was the Regulating Act of 1773 which removed diarchy as established by Lord Robert Clive. The act provided for converting the Governor of Bengal into the Governor –General of all the British territories in India and on the top of that proposed an Executive Council consisting of four members to help him take decisions with the majority of the council members. Warren Hastings, who was appointed as the first Governor General, tried to control corruption practices in the company’s bureaucracy. The Pitt’s India Act of 1784 created a Board of Commissioners to overlook the civil and military administration of the Company, thus, bringing the two under the effective subordination of the Government in England. Lord Cornwallis became the Governor General in 1786. He brought the concept of the covenanted and non-covenanted service in the Company’s bureaucracy. The covenanted service had recruits exclusively from the British and Europe and the Indian Civil Service is widely regarded as its successor. Cornwallis succeeded in removing corruption to a large extent from the bureaucracy by offering high pay scales. The Charter Act of 1853 proposed that all the citizens of British kingdom, which included Indians, to join the services .But, in practical terms, getting into the services remained a tough task for Indians as the exam centre was located in England and the maximum age to write the exam was too low for the Indians. The ICS Act of 1861 established the Indian Civil Service. Before 1861, only British officers could apply for the covenanted posts. Sir Charles Aitchison Commission in 1886 suggested that services should be organized into three classes- Imperial Indian Civil Services, the Provincial and the Subordinate Service – with the former to be recruited in England and the later out of Indians. He also suggested that the minimum and the maximum age be set at 19 and 23 years respectively. In 1918, the Montague-Chelmsford Commission, agreed on holding of the examination both in India and England. It also proposed that one-third of the superior posts in the Indian Civil Services should be recruited in India and that this proportion be increased by 1.5% per year. The commission also stated that discrimination based in racial terms in the appointments had to be eradicated. The Government of India Act, 1919, recommended that a Public Service Commission be established. Through the Government of India Act, 1935, Federal Public Service Commission was created. Although several efforts were made to make the services more acceptable to the Indian masses, but the services in the colonial times was essentially a colonial instrument to rule over large territories of British India.
The first Indian to join the Indian Civil Service was Satyendranath Tagore, [3] the elder brother of Rabindranath Tagore. Satyendranath Tagore went to England in 1862 to prepare for and compete in the civil service examinations and was selected for the Indian Civil Service in June, 1863. He completed his probationary training and returned to India in November 1864. During the course of his service, he travelled throughout the country and retired from ICS in 1897.
Indian Civil Service after Independence
Indian political [4] leaders and the general masses viewed the Imperial Civil Service as an apparatus of imperial domination, but by 1947, Indian political class had understood the advantages of a highly qualified institutionalized administration in place, more so, at a time when social fabric of the nation was threatening the national unity and law and order, basically, the nation was in turmoil. The present day civil service of India is mostly followed on the pattern of the Imperial Civil Service of the British India. It was formed after Independence of India in 1947 from the British India. Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel was of the view that Civil Services of independent India should play a key role in strengthening the national unity and in the development of India. The civil services have provided a steel frame for the administration of India. The key virtues of integrity, impartiality and merit remain the some of the established principles on which the Indian civil services function.
The constitution has provided Rajya Sabha (upper house of the Parliament of India) the power to create new All India Civil Services by a two-thirds majority. The Indian Forest Service, Indian Administrative Service and Indian Police Service were established by using this very constitutional provision.
The main role of the civil services is in carrying out administrative works of the Government of India efficiently. To achieve the above goal, the civil servants work together to get the maximum out of the natural, economic and human resources of the country. They are part of a number of governmental corporations that overlook the different policy matters and policies that govern the present and future of the nation. From playing the role of administrator on behalf of the central and state governments; tax collectors and revenue commissioners ; police ; ambassadors and diplomats; etc. , the civil servants play a diverse roles in the government functioning. The Chief of the Cabinet Secretariat of Republic of India is the highest ranked civil services official and the head of all civil services under the rules of business of the Government of India. He/She is also the Cabinet Secretary. Besides, He/She is ex-officio Chairman of the Civil Services Board. In the Order of precedence of India he/she ranks 11th. The Civil Services of India can be broadly divided into two kinds: the All India Services and the Central Civil Services. While the All India Services include Indian Administrative Service, Indian Forest Service and Indian Police Service, the Central Civil Service includes Indian Revenue Service Indian Foreign Service, Indian Engineering Service, etc. The Central Service is further divided into two groups: Group A services and Group B services. Besides the Indian Civil Service, there are state civil services for respective states which work for the states. The officers of the All India Services are trained by the central government and serve the various state governments as well as the central government. On the other hand the officers from Central Civil Services work only for the central government. Examinations are conducted each year by the Union Public Service Commission to induct new officers each year. The officers of the All India Services are further allocated cadres and have to work in the state whose cadre they have been allotted. They can also work with the central government when posted on deputation.
Indian Administrative Service
In 1947, Patel [5] inaugurated a new cadre modeled on the Indian Civil Service of the imperial era. This was known as the Indian Administrative Service. Although there are a number of other services like Indian Police Service, Indian Revenue Service, Indian Forest Service, etc. who play a huge and key role in their respective fields, the role of IAS in the growth of the modern Indian state has been commendable. The IAS officers work on different and huge variety of fields like irrigation management, conducting elections, supervising developmental programs, health care, state owned industries, etc. It is an elite service with elite officers who rise to occasions of crisis, for example after 2004 Tsunami, the Tamil Nadu IAS officers did a commendable job in relief and rehabilitation measures. There have cases where the timely response of IPS officers prevented law and order situations from getting out of hand. Although there have been complaints of corruption in IAS, but the service’s contributions to the nation can’t be denied. The civil services act as a bridge between the state and the society. Theses administrators in the course of their work meet thousands and thousands of people from all spheres of life and they try to get their grievances resolved. The role of IAS and other present day services is considerably tougher as they are obliged to pay close attention to what people think and demand.
In the end we can say for sure that the bureaucracy is a strong institution which performs varied roles. Their contribution to the nation building has been immense. There have been noteworthy civil servants like Sukumar Sen, ICS , who conducted the first ever elections in India, K.P.S.Gill IPS , who played a great role in stemming the insurgency in Punjab, who have served the nation with their grit , determination and have carried on the great traditions of the Indian Civil Service by being excellent administrators. The future of India hinges a great deal on the civil servants of today and future..
References
[1] “By 1850 or so, the Indian civil service was the best in the world” Saneev Sabhlok blog. (http://sabhlokcity.com/2011/04/by-1850-or-so-the-indian-civil-service-was-the-best-in-the-world)
[2] http://www.go4ias.com/posts/list/articles-evolution-of-civil-services-in-india-during-british-rule-802675.htm
[3] http://www.thecolorsofindia.com
[4] “Administering India: The Indian Civil Service”, Ann Ewing, History Today, Volume: 32, Issue: 6,1982 .
[5] “India After Gandhi”, Ramachandra Guha
Other sources: Wikipedia, Google search engine
nicely written!
ReplyDelete